Audrey Seiler was an athletic, popular and stellar student at the University of Wisconsin. Suddenly, the 20-year-old vanished and sent the city of Madison into a panic.

However, just as the town started to lose hope, Audrey was found, alone, in the woods. She was in perfect condition, but her story was full of holes.

Through forensic analysis and extensive interviews, investigators try to get to the bottom of this baffling case. The question remains, could Audrey herself be trusted?